Hey fellow book nerds! So most of you have probably seen it, but in case you didn’t know, yesterday the cover and title of the new Hunger Games prequel was revealed! So of course the big Hunger Games fan that I am, I decided to write my second discussion-type post and share my thoughts on it! (Today was supposed to be another writing WIP update, but we are definitely doing this instead. XD But I’m planning to still post it later this month!)
So…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
Here it is!
My thoughts on the cover:
Well…the cover itself is okay. I mean I’m glad it’s a different color, and it’s pretty similar to the original covers which is what I was hoping. The mockingjay symbol is definitely different, and compared to the others it kinda has a lot going on, but the more I look at it it’s grown on me. I like the branches and the mockingjay itself, and I think when we have the physical copies it it would look really pretty if they use gold foil. 😀 (Or make it at least somewhat reflective.)
Thoughts on the title:
The title…oh dear. Honestly, I’m disappointed. It’s like the publishers just said “Oh whatever let’s just use ‘The Blank of Blank and Blank‘ cookie cutter YA fantasy formula. Nobody will care! It’s The Hunger Games, it’s not like nobody is going to buy this book.” And didn’t put much thought into it at all!
Ahem, we care! It’s The Hunger Games, not another run of the mill YA fantasy! No offense to the books that have titles like this; I know a lot are really amazing, but…it in this case it just doesn’t fit! It’s not even fantasy! I mean I’m sure if someone heard this title, they wouldn’t think “Hunger Games.” They’d think…”Is that a new Sarah J. Maas book?” Or at least think it’s a fantasy of some sort.
I just think as far as trends go we might have gotten a little tired of seeing “the blank of blank and blank” formula, and seeing it on the return of such a well-loved series that was exempt from this trend because it didn’t really exist yet is just pretty disappointing. It doesn’t fit the simplicity of the rest of the series at all, and I think the straightforward titles were part of what made The Hunger Games series so iconic, because they kind of balance out the deep impact of the stories the books contain. It even would have been a little better if they cut out the “and snakes” part, called it “The Ballad of Songbirds” and left it at that. The title’s font doesn’t even match the titles of the rest of the series either!
Other thoughts:
Okay now that I’ve shared my main complaints, there are a couple positive things. The title did spark a new theory in my head that the story might have something to do with before the mockingjays were mutated? I don’t even clearly remember what they were mutated from, or when exactly, (I’m really looking forward to rereading the original trilogy!) but I’m pretty sure it was around the Dark Days? So if we get a little more backstory about that when it happened more recently it might be interesting?
Also, is the title a metaphor for the innocents being songbirds, and the capitol and possibly the career districts (and just all the bad people really) being the snakes?
Anyway, another thought I had was we know already that they are going to turn this book into a movie also. According to Goodreads it’s supposed to be over 500 pages, so are they going to break the movies up into parts like with Mockingjay? Even Mockingjay was only 390 pages…and they may think the title works now, but it’s kind of a mouthful for a movie, isn’t it? Ugh, are they going to end up changing it for the movie? If so, then why couldn’t they just call the book something simpler in the first place?!
So to sum up: I like the cover, but when I think of the title, I just cringe. I still have hope that it’s going to be good, but even with this new info, it still feels like the hype really isn’t that big. I’m starting to get a little worried.
All credit goes to the authors of the images.
What Do You Think?:
<a href=”Designed”>Designed”>Designed”>https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/blue-christmas-card-in-watercolor-style_816724.htm”>Designed by Freepik</a>
Credits:
<a href=”Designed”>Designed”>Designed”>http://www.freepik.com/free-vector/soft-background-with-a-cute-blue-watercolor-stain_1064674.htm”>Designed by Freepik</a>
Featured Image:
Book Cover:
Gif:
Awesome post!! I honestly feel the same about the title! It seems as though every fantasy YA novel being released in the past five years has to follow “the blank of blank and blank” formula. I wish this novel would’ve remained simple and straight forward like its predecessors. I DO like the cover well enough, and despite having a few gripes with the title, it is quite interesting! Fingers crossed that it’s a hit! ❤
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yay! I’m glad someone else agrees with my points. XD I’m still excited about it though!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am absolutely thrilled that we are getting more books in this series. I have never lost my ‘spark’ (hehe) for this trilogy–it has always been my absolute favorite and I am SO excited to read more in this world! That being said, I do share your opinion that the title is a sellout to the current YA fantasy formula. Who knows at this point, maybe there really is a reason for this? But right now, it just seems cliche and disappointing. The cover does work though and I like it. I am excited to find out how the symbols all fit together.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Me too! I’m still so excited! 😀
IKR? And it isn’t even a fantasy. It’s dystopian! I’m sure it does have a reason, but it’s still cliche. It would be great for any other book, but just not The Hunger Games.
LikeLike
The main problem I have is that neither the cover nor the title is consistent with the original trilogy. Like the title should have only been a few words long and the cover font doesn’t quite match…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah I have that same issue with it too. I like the cover design, but everything going on with the title is just…wrong. 😦
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m getting super excited and worried and super confused about this book!
I agree, the title is disappointing, but I am intrigued on how this will be handled within the THG universe!
– Emma 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
SO AM I! XD XD
I REALLY hope we get to learn a lot of cool new things about the worldbuilding, especially since it’s supposed to be almost twice as long as the original books. That’s what I’m most looking forward to. 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I agree with all your points! The title disappointed me too. It seemed a little generic🙈 Loved Reading the post 😊
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks! I’m glad you agree. XD
LikeLiked by 1 person
Amazing post Heather! I’m in the “I don’t care about this ” bandwagon , unfortunately. I still have to read the original books. On the thoughts on the cover , I think it’s just a rip off of serpent & dove. Even the symbol in the middle is similar!! And the name , oh God. I agree with you. It sounds like an amateur or debut fantasy.. it doesn’t match the theme of Hunger games at all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks!
Yeah, it does kind of look like it.
I know! It’s so sad! D: D:
LikeLike
I’m kind of meh with this whole prequel now lol. Before I was excited to hear the THG universe coming back, but now with this basic green cover and the title that’s too long, I’m not so sure anymore. I’m also tired of the “blank of blank and blank” formula. It’s too long!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know! I’m so worried now, but I really hope the story will still be good. I’m excited to reread the series for the first time in prep for it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Urg, yea that title is awful!! And the cover is .. boring? Its just not doing it for me. You are totally right about the title and I think the cover falls into this too – They are just cookie cutter YA. Meh
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know it’s so disappointing! D: D: D:
LikeLiked by 1 person